A year after plane crash, Ethiopians mull how to honour the dead

Gebru Ketema was outside tending cattle on the morning when Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302 plunged from the sky into a field near his village, killing all 157 people on board.

In the hectic days that followed, he and his neighbours welcomed rescue workers into their homes, offering meals and "sharing in the grief", he recalls.

A year later, the crash site -- now surrounded by an unfinished wooden fence -- sees little activity besides visits from mourners bearing flowers.

"This place has become famous because of the crash. We've been told they will put some kind of monument here, but the plan appears to be stuck," said Gebru.

Ahead of the one-year anniversary of the crash on Tuesday, Ethiopian Airlines has said little about how it might develop the site.

As recently as January, it hoped to use the anniversary to announce the winner of an architectural design competition for a memorial, according to a draft document on the plans seen by AFP.

But that plan now appears to be on hold after the document drew pushback from some victims' families, who objected to what they perceived as a rushed timeline, according to Zekarias Asfaw, who lost his brother in the crash.

A year later, the crash site of Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302 is surrounded by an unfinished wooden fence. By MICHAEL TEWELDE (AFP)

The dust-up highlighted concerns about whether Ethiopian Airlines was committed to honouring the dead in a sensitive way, said Zekarias, who serves on a committee involved in discussions about a possible memorial.

"You're rushing it because you're not valuing it," Zekarias said of the state-run airline, which did not respond to requests for comment.

"You have a company desperate to move on, and you have families saying, 'No, we haven't even had a chance to come together and start this journey'."

A 'lack of empathy'?

The proposed design competition was expected to attract bids for both a monument and a park, according to the document dated January 24.

The monument could feature "contemplation areas" and a visitors' centre, while suggested elements of the park included footpaths and trees.

After reviewing bids, judges were to make a selection by March 7, with a public exhibition for the winner to begin on March 10 -- the one-year anniversary.

Debris from the crash of Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302, which killed all 157 people on board on March 10, 2019. By Michael TEWELDE (AFP/File)

Objections to plans for the competition went beyond the tight turnaround, Zekarias said.

Some families pointed out that the document referred to victims exclusively as "men and women", even though children were among the passengers.

Overall, the document -- which in several places cites Wikipedia as a source for basic information on the crash -- was slapdash to the point of unprofessional, Zekarias said.

"As an Ethiopian, I'm also embarrassed by how they handled the whole thing," he said. "The lack of professionalism, the lack of empathy."

Small-scale memorials

At the headquarters of the Airline Pilots' Association of Ethiopia, members named a football pitch after Yared Getachew, the captain of Flight 302 who had been an avid player. By MICHAEL TEWELDE (AFP)

In the absence of an official memorial, at least two smaller sites honouring Flight 302 victims have been set up in the capital Addis Ababa in the past year.

At the headquarters of the Airline Pilots' Association of Ethiopia, members named a football pitch after Yared Getachew, the captain of Flight 302 who had been an avid player.

A plaque for Yared is mounted on a concrete wall along one of the sidelines, bearing the inscription "FOREVER LOVED".

Across town, the Holy Trinity Cathedral houses a memorial for Yared and the 16 other Ethiopian fatalities.

Plaques there feature two photos of each victim and a black-and-white Ethiopian Airlines logo.

The cathedral is the final resting place for dignitaries including former Emperor Haile Selassie and Prime Minister Meles Zenawi.

The Holy Trinity Cathedral houses a memorial for Yared and the 16 other Ethiopian fatalities. By MICHAEL TEWELDE (AFP)

So it was only appropriate for Flight 302 victims to be honoured there too, Priest Hadis Abab Tsegazeab told AFP.

"They are here because Ethiopian Airlines is the biggest airline in Africa and because its contribution to the nation is not small," Hadis said.

Private remembrances

Flight 302 victims are also honoured privately, even by people who had no direct connection to the tragedy.

Yared Getachew, a lawyer based in Addis, remembers the sadness he felt when he learned of the crash, followed by surprise when he realised he had the same name as the captain.

Though he knew no one on the plane, he decided to attend a memorial at Holy Trinity Cathedral in the days after the crash "to pass on my condolences".

In the year since the accident, he and his 12-year-old son Isaac have developed a ritual to remember the dead every time they fly.

Yared Getachew, a lawyer based in Addis, was surprised when he realised he had the same name as the captain. By MICHAEL TEWELDE (AFP)

Before the crash, Isaac, an aviation buff, would typically spend takeoffs telling his father everything that was happening: what the pilots were doing, or how flaps and slats on the wings worked to generate lift.

These days, though, Yared and Isaac start a timer on their phones and sit in silence for six minutes: the amount of time it took Flight 302 to go down.

"We really quietly try to imagine what they went through," Yared said.

"How difficult it must have been for those inside the plane... Even the slightest turbulence when you're on a plane is extremely frightening. So for about six minutes after takeoff we try to remember all those victims."