Sinking Ships and Soaring Eagles: The Profitability Gap Between Ghana’s SOEs and Private Enterprises

In Ghana, a stark contrast exists between the financial performance of private enterprises and state-owned enterprises (SOEs). While private companies often achieve profitability through efficient operations and market-driven strategies, many SOEs continue to struggle with financial losses, raising concerns about governance, operational efficiency, and fiscal management. This analysis examines the factors contributing to this disparity, supported by current data and case studies.

Governance and Accountability
Private companies operate under governance structures that emphasize accountability, profitability, and shareholder value. Decision-making processes are streamlined, with leadership appointments based on merit and performance. This framework fosters a culture of efficiency and responsiveness to market dynamics. In contrast, SOEs often face challenges related to political interference and bureaucratic inefficiencies. Leadership appointments within SOEs are sometimes influenced by political considerations rather than expertise, leading to ineffective management. The Finance Minister, Dr. Cassiel Ato Forson, recently highlighted that almost all SOEs are operating at a loss, underscoring the need for governance reforms.

Financial Performance and Debt Accumulation
Private enterprises maintain financial discipline, focusing on profitability and sustainable growth. Their ability to adapt to market conditions and implement cost-control measures contributes to their financial health. SOEs, on the other hand, have been accumulating significant debts. Reports indicate that the collective debt of SOEs has surpassed GH₵200 billion, reflecting systemic issues in financial management. The Electricity Company of Ghana (ECG) reported losses that escalated from GH₵1.46 billion in 2021 to GH₵8 billion in 2022 before slightly reducing to GH₵5.96 billion in 2023. The Ghana Cocoa Board (COCOBOD) has also recorded substantial losses, with GH₵2.4 billion in 2021 and GH₵3.8 billion in both 2022 and 2023. These financial struggles are attributed to factors such as government-imposed pricing controls, poor financial management, and inefficiencies.

Operational Efficiency and Market Dynamics
The competitive landscape compels private companies to innovate and optimize operations continually. They invest in technology, employee development, and process improvements to maintain a competitive edge.

Many SOEs operate in monopolistic environments, which can lead to inefficiencies. COCOBOD has struggled with declining cocoa production due to the government’s inability to address illegal gold mining and pricing issues. Despite increased government-set cocoa prices, the depreciation of the cedi has left farmers' incomes trailing behind global market trends, leading to smuggling activities. The Electricity Company of Ghana has also faced revenue collection challenges, with unpaid bills from government institutions contributing to its financial woes.

Dividend Contributions and Fiscal Impact
Companies with government minority shareholding have been significant contributors to state revenue. In 2023, these firms paid GH₵139.7 million in dividends, accounting for 71.89 percent of the total dividends received by the government. Fully government-owned SOEs, however, have underperformed in dividend contributions. In 2023, they contributed only GH₵6.2 million, representing a mere 3.19 percent of total dividends. This disparity highlights inefficiencies within wholly state-owned entities and their limited fiscal contributions.

Strategic Recommendations for SOE Reform
SOEs must undergo governance reforms to ensure that leadership appointments are based on expertise rather than political considerations. Financial discipline should be enforced through regular audits, stricter compliance measures, and improved revenue collection strategies. Operational efficiency must be prioritized by adopting best practices from the private sector, including lean management, technological innovation, and employee performance incentives. SOEs should also align pricing and operational policies with market realities to ensure sustainability, particularly in sectors like energy and agriculture. Public-private partnerships (PPPs) offer an opportunity to leverage private sector expertise, investment, and efficiency in managing state assets and services.

The financial disparity between private enterprises and state-owned enterprises in Ghana highlights the need for urgent reforms in governance, financial management, and operational efficiency. By adopting strategies that promote efficiency, accountability, and market responsiveness, SOEs can improve their profitability and contribute more effectively to national development.

Sources
Reuters: For Ghana’s cocoa farmers, fertiliser is the vote winner in looming election

Financial Times: How illegal gold mining is fuelling a chocolate shortage

Graphic Online: SOE crisis: Only three state-owned enterprises paid dividends in 2024 – Finance Minister

Public Sector Magazine: Ghana: State-Owned Enterprises paid over GH₵194 million in dividends to govt in 2023

MyJoyOnline: State-Owned Enterprises' debt crosses GH₵200 billion