From Bribery to Efficiency: Using Traffic Light Systems to Combat Corruption in Ghana's Passport Offices

"A corrupt society can have no future, only a past that keeps repeating itself." Robert Black

Ghana is in the midst of a digital transformation, with various sectors of government and public services migrating to online platforms in a bid to improve efficiency and reduce corruption. The country has embraced the move toward a more connected, digitised government as a solution to many of its longstanding issues, from online passport applications to digital health services. However, beneath this wave of optimism lies a critical question: Are Ghana’s digitisation platforms truly robust enough to achieve their intended goals, or are they too rudimentary to tackle corruption and inefficiency?

The passport acquisition process, despite its recent modernization efforts through online applications, continues to face severe challenges rooted in corruption. Despite the introduction of an online application system to enhance transparency and efficiency, some passport officers continue to manipulate the process to expedite applications for individuals who are willing to pay bribes. This perpetuates a system where financial status dictates the speed of service, undermining public trust in government institutions.

A potential solution to this issue is the Traffic Light Management System (TLMS), an automated system that could eliminate the influence of officers over the passport application process. By compelling all applications to follow a set protocol, regardless of social or financial status, and triggering automatic alerts if delays occur, this system can curb the widespread corruption plaguing Ghana’s passport offices.

Corruption in Ghana’s Passport Acquisition Process: Officers' ability to circumvent the system still taints Ghana's passport acquisition process, despite the shift to an online system. Applicants often resort to bribery to expedite their applications, leaving others to wait. Ordinary applications, which should take weeks, sometimes take months unless bribes are paid. Similarly, passport officers may delay express applications, intended for processing in a few days, unless they offer a "special fee". Lack of transparency and insufficient accountability fuel this unequal access.

The Traffic Light Management System (TLMS): A Transparent and Efficient Solution

to prevent officers from manipulating the system, the TLMS provides a framework that enforces a strict, transparent, and fair application process. Here's how the system would work in Ghana’s passport offices:

Application Submission and Colour Coding: The system assigns a "colour" to an online-submitted application based on its type and status. For example:

o Green Light: This refers to new applications that are submitted within the specified timeframe for either ordinary or express processing.

o The Yellow Light indicates applications that require additional documentation or information.

o Red Light: This feature automatically triggers an alert for investigation when applications exceed the standard processing time.

First-Come, First-Served Basis: The TLMS ensures that applications are processed on a first-come, first-served basis, without the possibility for passport officers to expedite applications based on bribes or personal connections. Officers would have no control over which applications to prioritize, as the system processes them according to their submission time.

One of the key features of TLMS is the alert system. If an application’s processing goes beyond the stipulated time, such as 15 days for ordinary processing or 5 days for express processing, it triggers an automatic alert that is sent to an independent monitoring body. This alert would prompt an immediate investigation to determine the reason for the delay and hold any responsible officers accountable. This eliminates the opportunity for officers to delay applications to extort applicants.

The task of investigating delays and irregularities would fall to a dedicated, independent body. This body would have access to the system and monitor the activities of passport officers. If any officer is found to have manipulated the process or caused unwarranted delays, strict sanctions, including fines, suspension, or even termination would be imposed.

Global Examples of TLMS and Similar Systems
Several countries have implemented systems similar to the Traffic Light Management System with tremendous success, particularly in curbing corruption and improving efficiency in public services.

• Estonia: Estonia is a global leader in e-government services, offering citizens digital access to almost all public services. Estonia's use of a transparent, tiered management system in handling applications for government services has drastically reduced opportunities for corruption. The system ensures strict timelines for application processing by monitoring and tracking their progress. Any delay automatically flags an issue for review, preventing manipulation by public officers.

• India's Passport Seva Project revolutionized passport issuance through a combination of online applications and digital tracking systems. The system processes applications based on the time of submission, leaving no room for officers to manipulate the order of service. In addition, delays beyond stipulated deadlines prompt automatic reviews by higher authorities, further reducing opportunities for corruption.

• Kenya: Kenya’s eCitizen platform allows citizens to access government services, including passport applications, through an online system that minimizes human interaction. This system has helped reduce the level of bribery and corruption that was previously rampant in passport issuance. In cases where delays occur, the system flags these issues for investigation, which ensures greater accountability.

How the TLMS Can Transform Ghana’s Passport Offices

Implementing a TLMS in Ghana would have significant positive outcomes for both the passport offices and the public.

• Elimination of Bribery: With TLMS, passport officers would be unable to fast-track applications based on bribery. The system would follow a strict queue based on the time of application submission, and officers would have no control over the speed of processing. This would greatly reduce the opportunities for officers to demand bribes from applicants seeking faster service.
• All applicants, regardless of their social or financial status, would receive equal treatment under the TLMS. The system would ensure that an applicant who follows the standard procedure receives their passport in the promised time without needing to offer bribes. The transparency of the system would boost public confidence in the passport application process.
• Increased Accountability: The alert system would hold passport officers accountable for any delays in processing applications. When applications delay beyond the specified time, the system automatically sends alerts to an independent body, prompting investigations and necessary sanctions. The swift detection of any manipulation would deter passport officers from engaging in corrupt practices.
• Improved Efficiency: The TLMS would significantly improve the overall efficiency of passport processing. Applicants would know exactly when to expect their passports, and any delays would be promptly addressed. This predictability would make it easier for Ghanaians to plan their travels while also reducing the administrative burden on passport offices.

While the TLMS offers a promising solution to the issues of corruption and inefficiency in Ghana’s passport offices, its successful implementation will require addressing several challenges:

• Technical Infrastructure: Ghana must invest in the necessary technical infrastructure to support the TLMS. This includes secure servers, reliable internet access, and system integration with the current online application platform.
• Training for Staff: Passport office staff would require comprehensive training on how to use the TLMS, ensuring that they fully understand how to operate the system and their reduced role in controlling the pace of application processing.
• Public Awareness: It would be essential to educate the public about the new system to discourage them from offering bribes to passport officers. An effective public awareness campaign would explain how the TLMS ensures fair and equal treatment for all applicants, regardless of wealth or social connections.
• Robust oversight mechanisms: To effectively monitor the system and investigate any alerts triggered by delays, we must empower an independent oversight body. This body would need to be free from political influence or corruption itself, ensuring that it can hold passport officers accountable without interference.

In conclusion, the introduction of the Traffic Light Management System (TLMS) in Ghana’s passport offices could mark the beginning of a new era of transparency, fairness, and efficiency in passport acquisition. The TLMS would ensure equal treatment for all applicants, irrespective of their financial status, by eliminating officers' ability to manipulate the system and expediting applications for bribes. With global examples proving the effectiveness of such systems, Ghana has an opportunity to overhaul its passport processing operations, reduce corruption, and restore public trust in government institutions.

"A transparent and accountable governance structure is key to eliminating corruption and building trust with citizens." Kofi Annan

[email protected]