Let us be honest before we celebrate.
We did not go to COP31 to win applause. We went to COP31 to win cash. Cash for farmers whose maize is dying in the field. Cash for coastal cities watching the sea eat their roads. Cash for mothers walking further for water every year.
In Antalya, the ministers got the microphone. Miriam got the queue.
COP31 was supposed to end in Antalya, Türkiye, on 20 November 2026. As of Friday night, there was still no consensus. Talks had run past deadline. COP has not finished on time since 2003.
That delay tells you everything. The summit did not end with a decision. It ended with a splinter.
We cause about 4% of global greenhouse gas emissions. Four percent. Yet we are paying the highest price in drought, floods, and food insecurity. Some estimates put the loss to floods, droughts and heat we did not cause at 2 to 5% of GDP every year, while hundreds of millions of us still have no power.
We need about US$70 billion a year¹ just to adapt. Just to survive what we did not cause.
Did we get it? No.
Did we win something? Yes. But we must name it correctly.
We won process. Not money.
THE CONTRACT THAT WAS BETRAYED LONG BEFORE ANTALYA
COP stands for Conference of the Parties. Nearly 200 countries signed the contract in Rio in 1992 — the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. COP exists to govern it. Not as charity. As the governing body of a treaty. That contract was betrayed long before Antalya.
Copenhagen in 2009 promised $100 billion a year² by 2020. We got PowerPoints, consultants, and loans counted as aid. Paris in 2015 was the apology. It promised to keep warming below 2 degrees, aiming for 1.5. We fought for 1.5 because 2 degrees is death for the Sahel. We won on paper. But Paris had no court. No fine. No jail.
Antalya, hailed as the implementation COP, was supposed to be where the paper became payment. It was not.
THE TEST IS THE TAP, NOT THE TEXT
The women I call Miriam live in Chivi, Masvingo. A few years ago their boreholes gave water close to the surface. Then the water table fell. In early 2026, many gave dust.
Now they walk for hours each morning to a communal borehole. They queue. They carry water back on their heads. By the time they return, children have often left for school without breakfast, because there was no water to cook.
Their maize gives far less than their fathers' fields gave on the same soil a generation ago. Same soil. Different rain.
They did not cause climate change. Most have never flown. Most have never owned a car. Their footprint is a cooking fire. Yet they pay with their backs, their time, and their children's education.
Do not make them only victims. The women I met chair their village water committees. They keep ledgers. They know which borehole works, which driller cheated, which family did not pay. When a solar pump comes, they will not just carry water. They will own it.
Miriam is the reason COP31 matters. And Miriam is the reason COP31 failed.
WHAT WE WON
1. We held the line. We did not break.
54 nations. One bloc. One voice — on principle.
The African Group of Negotiators, led by Ghana's Dr. Antwi Amoah, refused to let rich countries reopen the Paris Agreement and water down what was already promised. When they tried to push the burden back onto us, we said no. Together.
That does not happen by accident. That is discipline.
In a COP where everyone was tired, divided, and ready to sell out the small countries, we stayed united on principle. That is a win. A real win.
2. The draft proposed a standalone finance track.
The second draft proposed a standalone Climate Finance Work Programme.
That sounds boring. It is not boring. If adopted, it would mean finance can no longer be buried inside other paragraphs and forgotten. It would have its own track. Its own table. Its own fight.
We demanded that. The draft included it. It was not yet adopted.
3. The draft proposed a roadmap with our name on it.
The Antalya-to-Addis Ababa Roadmap on Adaptation and Resilience Finance.
Antalya is where we are. Addis Ababa is where we are going. COP32 will be in Addis Ababa in November 2027. We will host.
The roadmap, if adopted, is supposed to identify predictable, scaled-up finance, including for loss and damage. And the Standing Committee on Finance would, if adopted, prepare a technical report on what "tripling adaptation finance" actually means — what is the baseline, what counts, what progress has been made.
That is process. But process matters when we are the host. It means next year, the world must answer to us, on African soil.
4. We won the moral argument.
We have won the climate argument.
How can you argue with a continent that emits 4% and suffers far more than its share of the consequences? You cannot. We believe we are owed. We believe the debt is real.
That is why Power Shift Africa's Mohamed Adow could stand up on Friday, November 20, and reject the COP presidency's claim of success — and the room listened. Because we were not begging. We were telling the truth.
We did not go to beg. We went to collect a debt.
WHAT WE LOST
Now the failure. Say it plainly.
1. We lost the dedicated agenda item.
We wanted a dedicated agenda item on tripling adaptation finance. A permanent place on the agenda where tripling is discussed, tracked, enforced.
The agenda item was not adopted.
The draft proposed a work programme. The draft proposed a roadmap. The draft proposed a technical report. We did not get the agenda item. That means tripling can still be pushed aside.
2. We lost the number.
This is the biggest failure.
On 16 November, the first draft was 18 pages. It had language about moving away from fossil fuels, and a figure for adaptation finance — US$120 billion a year³ by 2035.
On 19 November, the second draft was 9 pages. Both were gone.
Zero words on coal, oil or gas. Zero mention of US$120 billion. In its place: a proposal to "triple adaptation finance" with no baseline, no delivery pathway, no new pledges.
Let us be precise about whose number this was. This was not Africa's number alone. This was a developing-country number — pushed by the G77 and China, the Least Developed Countries, and the Alliance of Small Island States, with Africa as part of that coalition. At COP30 in Belem, the world agreed to "triple adaptation finance." Beautiful words. No numbers attached. At COP31, developing countries said: define it. Make it US$120 billion a year by 2035. That is tripling the $40 billion⁴ Glasgow baseline. Put it in writing.
The second draft omitted that figure. Deleted. Gone.
So we still have a proposal to triple something, without agreeing what that something is. That is not a promise. That is a slogan.
And while they argue about definitions, look at the real numbers: public adaptation finance grew by only about US$1 billion⁵ between 2023 and 2024. One billion. Against needs of about US$305 billion a year⁶ globally.
One billion is an insult, not an increase.
The draft text itself cited those needs — US$305 billion a year for adaptation alone to 2035, according to UNEP. Then it offered no number to meet it.
It also reflected, for the first time at a COP, the UNEP assessment that the world is now set to fail to hold warming to 1.5 degrees.
3. We lost grants. We got loans.
We did not go to Antalya to ask for more debt.
We asked for grant-based money. Money that does not have to be paid back with interest while your village is still underwater.
Wealthy nations resisted. They resisted new public spending. They resisted grant floors.
So we are still left to rely on loans and old pledges. Loans for a crisis we did not create. That is not climate finance. That is climate debt.
We needed grants, not debt dressed as climate finance. Instead we got workshops.
4. We lost on fossil fuels. And we were divided on it too.
The draft released on Thursday, November 19, dropped references to ending fossil fuel use. It weakened language on electrification. It weakened language on adaptation finance.
No explicit language on transitioning away from fossil fuels. No phasing down coal, oil, and gas.
Panama said it would block consensus. At least 23 countries objected. 25 countries then announced on 20 November they would publish their own roadmaps away from fossil fuels — because COP would not do it.
African climate advocates called it what it was: betrayal.
But let us not pretend Africa spoke with one voice on this. We did not.
Developing countries were divided on oil. Africa was divided on oil. Especially our oil-producing countries — Nigeria, Angola, Algeria, Libya, and others who depend on oil revenue — do not want the same fossil fuel language as the Sahel states watching their land turn to desert, or the island states watching the sea rise.
That division is real. It weakened our bargaining power. When we cannot agree among ourselves whether to name oil, the rich world does not have to name it either.
How do you hold a climate summit and refuse to name the thing heating the planet? You don't. Unless you are protecting the polluters — and unless some of us are protecting our own oil too.
That is why many are calling this "the worst COP ever".
They are not wrong.
WE ALSO FAILED. AND HARARE FAILED TOO.
And if we are honest about the world, we must be honest about ourselves.
We held the line on principle. We splintered on detail.
We held the line on Paris. But on the number, on fossil fuels, on who gets what first — there we had 54 positions. We did not speak with one voice on the details, then we complained the room did not listen.
And let me be brutal about home. I propose a National Water Fund in Zimbabwe, funded by 2% of mining royalties. Harare is my example. Lagos, Nairobi, Accra,Yaounde know this story too.
But you in Chivi are right to think that money will disappear. Zimbabwe already has laws that say mining royalties should benefit communities. They don't. We have seen water tenders captured before. A women's committee that refuses to sign off on a fake borehole does not get praised. It gets threatened.
Publishing a ledger does not stop theft. Publishing is what gets journalists threatened.
My proposal only works if it is not run by Harare alone. Money released borehole by borehole, only after the previous borehole is verified as working. No verification, no next payment. If Harare will not accept that, Harare is part of the problem — and so is any African capital that refuses the same test.
100 BOREHOLES, THEN ADDIS
This is my proposal, not Africa's consensus: drill 100 solar boreholes in 12 months in Chivi and Matabeleland South, Dete as an example, owned by women's committees. At US$25,000 to US$40,000 each⁷, that is US$2.5 to US$4 million⁸ for a pilot that can be audited.
100 boreholes will not save Africa. They will prove we can spend US$4 million cleanly. That is the bridge to the US$305 billion the draft itself cited as needed for adaptation.
Then when we walk into Addis Ababa in 2027 for COP32, we walk in as builders not beggars. I will lobby for a US$10 billion⁹ African Water Facility, grants only, AU-managed, with a public ledger. Not because the AU agreed it — it hasn't. Not because Addis will adopt it. Because someone has to put a costed number on the table and lobby for it, instead of another communique.
We have had 31 communiques. We need one contract.
We must arrive in Addis with three non-negotiables:
1. A firm figure. US$120 billion is the floor, not the ceiling.
2. Mostly grant-based money. Not loans.
3. A delivery timetable. When does the money leave the bank and reach the village?
If we don't, the world will do what it always does: praise us for being united, praise us for being moral, praise us for being patient — and pay us nothing.
THE VERDICT
So, did we succeed or fail at COP31?
Both.
Success: We won the argument. We won unity on principle. We got our language into the draft- a proposed standalone finance track, a proposed roadmap to Addis, a proposed technical report that would force the numbers into the open, if adopted.
Failure: We did not win money. We did not win US$120 billion. We did not win a dedicated agenda item. We did not win grants over loans. We did not win fossil fuel language. And we were divided on oil ourselves.
Process without money is a map without fuel. You can hold the map. You still cannot move.
But let me not lie at the end.
After COP31, Miriam will still be in the queue in 2027. The roadmap will not have built her a pump. The US$10 billion does not exist yet. The 100 boreholes are not drilled yet.
She will still walk. She will still queue. She will still carry water home while her children leave for school hungry.
That is the indictment.
We won the climate argument at COP31.
Now we must win the climate money at COP32.
Otherwise the argument was just poetry, and our people cannot drink or eat poetry.
NOTE: Miriam is a composite. Names changed, stories combined from women the author has listened to in Chivi, to protect their privacy.
FOOTNOTES — Sources & Author's Estimates
¹ US$70 billion a year: Africa's estimated adaptation needs. Global Center on Adaptation, _Africa Adaptation Acceleration Program_, based on African NDCs. Cited in Power Shift Africa, "Tripling adaptation finance is the floor, not the ceiling," Nov 2026, and Nation Africa, "COP31 must end the wait for Africa's adaptation finance," Nov 2026. Africa receives about $14bn a year against that need. Check: GCA / Power Shift Africa websites.
² $100 billion a year by 2020: Copenhagen Accord pledge, UNFCCC 2009. Pledge made, never fully delivered as grants. Check: UNFCCC Copenhagen Accord, 2009.
³ $120 billion a year by 2035: Figure proposed by developing countries at COP31, based on tripling the Glasgow baseline. Appeared in first draft, removed in second draft. UNFCCC COP31 Draft Cover Decisions, 16 Nov 2026 (18-page draft) and 19 Nov 2026 (9-page draft). This was a G77 + China / LDC / AOSIS proposal, not an Africa-only figure. Check: UNFCCC COP31 draft texts, via http://unfccc.int, and Reuters / Down To Earth coverage, 16-19 Nov 2026.
⁴ $40 billion Glasgow baseline: Baseline used for tripling calculation. Glasgow Climate Pact, UNFCCC 2021. Cited by African negotiators at COP31. Check: UNFCCC Glasgow Climate Pact, 2021.
⁵ About US$1 billion growth 2023-2024: Growth in public adaptation finance between 2023 and 2024. Cited in COP31 Draft Cover Decision, 16 Nov 2026, based on OECD _Climate Finance Provided and Mobilised_ data 2025. Check: UNFCCC COP31 draft, 16 Nov 2026, and OECD 2025 report.
⁶ US$305 billion a year: Global adaptation needs to 2035. Cited in COP31 Draft Cover Decisions, 16 and 19 Nov 2026, based on UNEP _Adaptation Gap Report 2026_. This is a draft figure, not an adopted final text. No final text had been adopted as of Friday night, 20 Nov 2026. Both drafts were wholly in brackets, meaning nothing was agreed. Check: UNFCCC COP31 drafts, and UNEP Adaptation Gap Report 2026.
Author Estimates
⁷ $25,000 to $40,000 per borehole: Author's estimate for a solar borehole in Chivi / Matabeleland South, based on UNICEF Zimbabwe solar borehole benchmarks and local driller quotes. Author's estimate, not a UN figure and not independently verifiable. Check: UNICEF Zimbabwe WASH programme benchmarks.
⁸ $2.5 to $4 million: Author's calculation: 100 boreholes x $25,000-$40,000. Pilot cost, not a UN figure.
⁹ $10 billion African Water Facility: Author's proposal to lobby for at COP32, not an AU-agreed figure. The AU has not adopted it.
F Madondo



NATO faces sovereignty dilemma as militaries rely on private tech, AI
Afenyo-Markin demands answers over poor water quality in Central Region
Mahama says Mayweather’s Ghana visit will boost tourism, boxing
Police to develop human rights manual to strengthen professionalism and public t...
How Korle Bu surgeons fixed back man's penis cut off whiles attempting to sit on...
German President to visit Ghana for talks on trade and skills development
Madina Court remands man over alleged GH¢18,500 theft from girlfriend
Akufo-Addo left Mahama govt GH¢680bn debt bill for 2027-2030 — Isaac Adongo
Bahrain accuses Iran of striking industrial site as tankers hit in Hormuz
Kwame Dzokoto to be laid to rest on February 20 in Sekondi
