body-container-line-1

A Trumpian Doctrine for Nigeria: Psychological and Physical Defeat of Jihadists and Bandits

John Egbeazien Oshodi, Forensic/Clinical Psychologist and Criminal Justice Specialist
WED, 18 NOV 2026
John Egbeazien Oshodi, Forensic/Clinical Psychologist and Criminal Justice Specialist

Nigeria must stop managing its armed groups and start defeating them: no negotiation, no ransoms, no pauses, until every fighting cell is broken.

At dawn on Sunday, 15 November 2026, gunmen stormed a mosque in Kaura Namoda, Zamfara State, during the Subhi prayer. They shot dead a worshipper, Nasiru Sani, and dragged others into the bush. It was not an exception. It was a Sunday in Nigeria.

This year alone, 177 worshippers were seized from three churches in Kurmin Wali, Kaduna, in January. Thirty-seven were taken from churches in Ariko on Easter Sunday; 17 of them died in captivity. Worshippers were shot at a prayer ground in Kwara in May and a pastor was killed in Plateau in September. Christians bleed, Muslims bleed, and the killers move on to the next village.

The time for dialogue, amnesty-first programmes and quiet truces is over. What Nigeria needs is a doctrine: overwhelming, relentless pressure on the bodies and the minds of those who kill, rape and burn. Call it the Trumpian way.

Seventeen years of half-measures
The war has lasted 17 years because Nigeria has never fought it to the finish. The insurgency has indirectly cost close to 350,000 civilian lives and displaced about 2 million people in the northeast.

The pattern repeats. An offensive gains ground, then funding dries up, an election arrives, or a ceasefire is whispered into being. The fighters melt into the Mandara mountains and the Lake Chad islands, rearm, and return.

Meanwhile the violence has spread. Bandit gangs and armed militias now raid Zamfara, Katsina, Kaduna, Kwara, Kogi, Plateau and Benue. Kwara, once one of Nigeria's quieter states, now counts attacks on its churches and prayer grounds.

The lesson is not that force has failed. It is that force has never been sustained.

Negotiation is deception
Every deal Nigeria has struck with armed groups has bought, at best, a pause, and at worst, the next attack. Defence Minister Christopher Musa said it plainly in January: "Negotiation is deception."

Yet the deals keep coming. In September, The New Humanitarian reported a secret ceasefire with the Bakura Doro faction of Boko Haram, in effect since June. It grew out of the release of 360 villagers abducted from Ngoshe, Borno, and reportedly involved a ransom of five billion naira, which the government denies.

Boko Haram's own judge later called the truce a fabrication and promised more attacks. Sources warned the group was using the lull to move equipment into the mountains. A government official admitted that past ceasefires, including the 2022/2023 truce, all collapsed.

The bandit file is no better. In January, Katsina State moved to release about 70 suspected bandits to keep a local peace deal alive. By May, North-West governors had ruled out further talks. Bandits, they concluded, use dialogue to regroup and rearm.

The research agrees. In RAND's study of terrorist groups since 1968, only 11 percent of religious groups ended through a political process. Groups like Boko Haram do not want a seat at the table. They want the table, the house and the village.

What the Trumpian model actually is
The Trumpian model is speed, firepower and a single goal: annihilation, not containment. In 2017, President Trump ordered an "annihilation" campaign against ISIS: surround the fighters and destroy them, rather than chase them from town to town.

Three changes made it work. Commanders in the field, not bureaucrats in Washington, approved strikes. US advisers embedded with partner forces could call in air and artillery directly. Local allies, Kurdish and Iraqi, did the fighting on the ground. Within two years, the ISIS caliphate had lost its territory.

Nigeria has already had a taste. On Christmas Day 2025, US Tomahawk missiles struck Islamic State targets in Sokoto State. US advisers arrived in February 2026 and drones in March. In May, a joint US-Nigerian operation killed Abu-Bilal al-Minuki, a senior ISWAP commander, followed by strikes that killed more than 20 fighters.

These were proof of concept. What Nigeria lacks is not the model but the will to apply it everywhere, against every armed group, without stopping.

The physical campaign: break their bodies

The physical campaign has one task: destroy the groups' ability to fight, move and feed themselves. Five pillars would carry it.

  1. Cut off the head, again and again. Boko Haram's imam, Ibrahim Bakura Doro, and his faction commanders, Alhai Kale, Abubakar Sadiku Saidu and Ali Ngulde, must become permanent targets. Research by Patrick Johnston found that a successful strike on top leaders raises the chance of government victory that year by 32 percent. When Abubakar Shekau died in 2021, tens of thousands left the bush.
  2. Surround, don't scatter. Box fighters into the Mandara mountains and the Lake Chad islands and destroy them there. That demands what Nigeria has never built: a real riverine and lake force.
  3. Seal the borders. Joint operations with Cameroon, Niger and Chad, so no fighter escapes to fight another day.
  4. Starve the loot economy. Boko Haram survives by looting and taxing civilians. Protect markets, roads and farms, prosecute the traders who buy their plunder, and control fuel for their boats and motorbikes.
  5. Watch everything. Persistent drone and satellite surveillance over the lake and the passes, feeding strikes in hours, not days.

The psychological campaign: break their will

The psychological campaign aims to make every fighter believe one thing: staying means death, and leaving means prison, not reward.

  • Certain death or certain justice. No amnesty on surrender. A fighter who walks out faces detention, debriefing and trial. One who brings his rifle, a captive or a commander's location earns a reduced sentence, not a welcome party.
  • Not one naira in ransom. Every payment buys weapons and the next kidnapping. A government that says it never pays must actually never pay.
  • Turn the family against the fighter. Messages in Kanuri and Hausa to mothers and fathers in home villages: your son can come home to a courtroom, or die on the lake.
  • Feed the feud. Boko Haram and ISWAP have lost more fighters fighting each other since 2021 than fighting the military. Nigeria should widen that crack with no deal at all.
  • Make every victory public. When a commander falls, the villages he terrorised should hear it on the radio the same day.

Pressure works when it is felt. Since 2021, more than 20,000 active male fighters have laid down arms, and the army credits sustained military pressure. Imagine what unbroken pressure would do.

Two enemies, one doctrine
The doctrine must cover the bandits as fiercely as the jihadists, because most attacks on worshippers this year came from bandit gangs and armed militias, not Boko Haram.

The jihadists of the northeast are driven by a twisted creed. The bandits of the northwest and north-central are driven by money: ransom, cattle and illegal gold. Different motives, same victims, same answer.

For the bandits, the psychology is economic. Make kidnapping unprofitable. Seize their cattle and their cash, prosecute the informants and middlemen who feed them, and end every state-level peace deal that releases suspects back into the bush.

Attacks on churches and mosques must be treated as terrorism, with rapid-response units for places of worship in the most exposed states. Every attack must be followed by arrests and public trials, as when Kwara police arrested 33 suspects over the November 2025 church attack in Eruku.

Ruthless to fighters, disciplined to civilians

The doctrine targets those who carry weapons, not those the killers drag behind them. That is not softness; it is how the war is won.

A man or woman holding a rifle or a suicide vest is a lawful target. The wives, captives and children in the camps are not. Many were abducted; many of the young bombers were forced. They are detained, screened and questioned, and the guilty are tried. Children are rescued.

This discipline is a weapon. Villagers do not trust the police or the army today, and a military without local trust fights blind. Drones can watch an island, but the tip that finds a commander comes from a fisherman, a trader or a woman who escaped.

So soldiers who loot or abuse must be punished as surely as terrorists are hunted. Every village that trusts the army is a hiding place the enemy has lost.

What the critics will say, and the answer

"You must understand the culture." Some Nigerians will say these groups grow from local grievances, religion and tradition, and must be handled with cultural sensitivity. My answer is simple: evil is evil. There is no culture in which shooting a man at dawn prayer is honourable, no tradition that blesses the rape of a captive girl, no faith that sanctifies burning a church full of worshippers. Understanding why a man picks up a gun does not oblige us to let him keep it.

"Force alone has never worked." RAND found that military force ended only 7 percent of terrorist groups, and that police and intelligence work ended 73 percent of religious ones. Fair. That is why this doctrine is built on intelligence, leadership strikes and local trust, not bombs alone. Force is the hammer; intelligence aims it.

"Killing leaders only creates new ones." Some scholars, such as Jenna Jordan, argue that large groups survive decapitation. Larger studies by Johnston and Bryan Price find the opposite: groups that lose their leaders end faster. Nigeria saw it with Shekau.

"No negotiation means abandoning hostages." This is the hardest objection, and the families of captives deserve an honest reply. The answer is a real rescue capability, special forces trained and equipped for hostage recovery, because every ransom paid today guarantees more hostages tomorrow.

"Communities closest to the war want dialogue." Many do, after 17 years of exhaustion. But the deals they were promised have collapsed every time. Peace bought from killers is rented, never owned.

Defeat is the only language
Nigeria's own government has said it: the only language terrorists understand is the language of defeat. It is time to speak it fluently, and without pause.

That means a funded, multi-year campaign that does not slacken for elections, budgets or whispered truces. It means hunting leaders until none dares lead, starving gangs until kidnapping no longer pays, and offering fighters only two exits: the grave or the courtroom.

It also means protecting every Christian and every Muslim the killers target, because they target both. Ruthless to the enemy, disciplined to the people: that is the Trumpian doctrine Nigeria needs. Evil is evil. Let us finally treat it so.

John Egbeazien Oshodi
John Egbeazien Oshodi, © 2026

Professor John Egbeazien Oshodi, PhD, is an American forensic and clinical psychologist, policing and corrections expert, criminal justice educator, researcher, author, and public scholar.. More His expertise spans forensic, legal, clinical, cross-cultural, and organizational psychology, criminal behavior, public safety, leadership, public ethics, governance, and institutional accountability.

A native of Uromi, Edo State, Nigeria, and son of a 37-year veteran of the Nigeria Police Force, Professor Oshodi has devoted his career to the intersection of psychology, justice, education, public policy, and institutional development. In 2011, he helped introduce advanced forensic psychology into Nigerian higher education through the National Universities Commission and Nasarawa State University, Keffi, where he served as Associate Professor of Psychology.

He teaches at Nova Southeastern University and Walden University and serves as Visiting Virtual Professor of Forensic and Clinical Psychology at Nasarawa State University, Keffi, Nigeria. He is also President and Chief Psychologist of the Oshodi Foundation, Center for Psychological and Forensic Services, United States.

Professor Oshodi is a Black Republican in the United States but belongs to no political party in Nigeria. His scholarship and public commentary are independent and guided by justice, constitutional democracy, good governance, institutional accountability, ethical leadership, and Africa's sustainable development.

He is the founder of Psychoafricalysis (Psychoafricalytic Psychology), a culturally grounded framework integrating African sociocultural realities, historical consciousness, indigenous knowledge, and future-oriented identity into psychological science and practice.

Professor Oshodi has authored more than 1,000 articles, multiple books, and numerous peer-reviewed publications on forensic and correctional psychology, policing, criminal justice, mental health, higher education, democracy, governance, and African development. His work with Africans, the African diaspora, and culturally diverse populations in the United States and internationally continues to inform his advocacy for culturally responsive psychology, ethical leadership, stronger institutions, and evidence-based public policy.
Column: John Egbeazien Oshodi

Disclaimer: "The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect ModernGhana official position. ModernGhana will not be responsible or liable for any inaccurate or incorrect statements in the contributions or columns here." Follow our WhatsApp channel for meaningful stories picked for your day.

Just in....
body-container-line