What happened. Experts from across Africa met in Accra on 3 November for the fourth regional symposium on commercial cyber intrusion capabilities (CCICs), the technical term that includes commercial spyware.
Expertise France supported it, in cooperation with Ghana's Cyber Security Authority and the Africa Internet Governance Forum. Around 70 participants took part, with the aim of raising awareness of the commercial spyware market and encouraging more African participation in the Pall Mall Process.
According to the post you shared, Communications Minister Samuel Nartey George, French Ambassador Diarra Dimé-Labille and UK Deputy High Commissioner Chris Halliday attended. I did not find a record of what any of them said.
What is the Pall Mall Process? The UK and France launched it in February 2024 to tackle the proliferation and irresponsible use of commercial cyber intrusion tools and services. In April 2025, 21 countries signed its Code of Practice for States in Paris, including Ghana.
The code now has 25 supporting countries, and it sets guidelines for developing, buying, transferring and using these capabilities. Through the EU-funded Capacity Building for Cybersecurity and AI programme, Expertise France helps put it into practice.
A second step, voluntary industry guidelines, recommends measures such as export-control compliance, risk assessments and technical access controls. The US signed on this week.
Why it matters in Africa. Spyware is not abstract for journalists, lawyers and activists. A coalition of rights groups, including the Media Foundation for West Africa, has documented at least 180 potentially targeted journalists in 21 countries.
A 2026 outcome report from a spyware summit says the abuse continues to affect countries across Africa. Its first edition was held in Accra in 2024. The danger for reporters goes beyond one device, because spyware can expose their sources, contacts and families.
The market is also hard to contain. Google's Threat Analysis Group has tracked around 40 distinct commercial spyware vendors.
Why Ghana is a natural host. As a code signatory with a Cyber Security Authority, Ghana can credibly convene the region. The Accra meeting also invites the question of what rules apply at home. Useful questions for the authorities are whether Ghana has procured any such tools, under what legal authority, and with what judicial oversight.
The other side. The process has critics who say voluntary codes are not enough. Rights groups say the industry guidelines fall short, and want mandatory kill switches, more transparency and stronger due diligence.
Freedom House calls the state code a step in the right direction but says it falls short in some areas and needs oversight to be implemented. Many civil society organisations and UN bodies have called for a complete moratorium on the sale and use of commercial spyware.
Supporters answer that engaging governments and industry, including controversial vendors, is more practical than waiting for a ban. Some vendors, including NSO Group, have reportedly begun engaging with the process, though early on. Governments also argue that some intrusion tools have legitimate uses, such as fighting terrorism and serious crime, when properly controlled.
The bottom line. The symposium shows the debate is moving from Europe and Washington to Africa. The test will be whether African states publish rules, set up independent oversight and say what they have bought, not just attend meetings.
Mustapha Bature Sallama
Medical/ Science Communicator,
Private Investigator, Criminal Investigation and Intelligence Analysis,
International Conflict Management and Peacebuilding. (USIP)
[email protected]
+233555275880
References
Stéphane Mortier, LinkedIn post on the 4th regional symposium, Accra, Nov 2026. https://www.linkedin.com/in/st%C3%A9phane-mortier-phd-95315837/
Sophie Louette, Expertise France, LinkedIn post on the Accra dialogue. https://www.linkedin.com/in/sophie-louette-446777113/
"22 countries led by UK and France unite against commercial spyware," Infosecurity Magazine, 7 Feb 2024. https://www.freevacy.com/news/infosecurity-magazine/22-countries-led-by-uk-and-france-unite-against-commercial-spyware/4846
"21 Countries Sign Onto Voluntary Pact to Stem the Proliferation of Spyware," Security Boulevard, Apr 2025. https://securityboulevard.com/2025/04/21-countries-sign-onto-voluntary-pact-to-stem-the-proliferation-of-spyware/
"Regulating Commercial Cyber Intrusion Capabilities," AFCEA Signal. https://www.afcea.org/signal-media/cyber-edge/regulating-commercial-cyber-intrusion-capabilities
"Industry guidelines for offensive cyber tools unveiled through international Pall Mall Process," CyberScoop. https://cyberscoop.com/pall-mall-process-commercial-spyware-guidelines/
"Spyware reform led by France and UK advances with new Code of Practice," Business & Human Rights Resource Centre, 9 Apr 2025. https://www.business-humanrights.org/en/latest-news/spyware-reform-led-by-france-and-uk-advances-with-new-code-of-practice-but-key-support-remains-uncertain
"How the Pall Mall Process Can Help Combat Commercial Spyware Abuse," Freedom House. https://freedomhouse.org/index%2ephp/article/how-pall-mall-process-can-help-combat-commercial-spyware-abuse
"Secret surveillance: countering spyware's threats to freedom of the press and expression," Access Now. https://www.accessnow.org/press-release/spyware-press-freedom-statement/
"Tackling Spyware Abuse," Just Security. https://www.justsecurity.org/156978/tackling-spyware-abuse-protect-journalists/
"Final Outcome Report, Second Spyware Summit," 2026. https://bpb-us-e2.wpmucdn.com/sites.uci.edu/dist/2/4290/files/2026/08/FINAL_Outcome-Report_Second-Spyware-Summit.pdf
"Friday Digest 11: Spyware Revelations," Top10VPN (Google TAG vendor count). https://top10vpn.substack.com/p/friday-digest-11-spyware-revelations



NDC enjoying benefits of NPP's difficult economic decisions – Fuseini Issah
Improved economy justifies purchase of new presidential jet – Toobu
Eight Ghanaian seafarers return home after months in Iranian detention
No one will be allowed to mess around with a Ghanaian and get away with it – Abl...
Exim Bank case: Wontumi offers GH¢25m to secure end to prosecution
Gov't finds $60.68m for presidential jet despite cost-of-living concerns – Abu J...
Mahama orders performance assessment of all 261 MMDCEs
Customs orders strict enforcement of permit requirement for right-hand steering ...
Fitch Solutions projects cedi will weaken to GH¢12.40 against dollar in 2027
I think Mahama done better than the first term – Archbishop Agyinasare
