A court in Tokyo has ruled that Samsung Electronics did not infringe on patents held by Apple, a victory for the South Korean company.
The patent was related to transferring media content between devices.
It comes after Samsung lost a key patent case in the US last week and was ordered to pay more than $1bn (£664m) in damages.
This is one of many cases brought to courts around the world by the two smartphone market leaders.
"We welcome the court's decision, which confirmed our long-held position that our products do not infringe Apple's intellectual property," said Samsung in a statement to the BBC.
Tokyo District Judge Tamotsu Shoji dismissed the case filed by Apple in August, finding that Samsung was not in violation of Apple patents related to synchronising music and video data between devices and servers.
Sales ban
On 24 August, a US court ruled Samsung had infringed Apple patents for mobile devices, including the iPhone and iPad.
The company has vowed to continue to fight against Apple saying it will appeal against the US ruling.
Apple is now seeking a ban on sales of eight Samsung phones in the US market.
On 6 December, US District Judge Lucy Koh, who presided over the initial trial, will hear Apple's plea for an injunction against the Samsung phones, although it does not include the most recent Samsung phone to hit the market, the Galaxy S3.


Nyinahin Catholic SHS teacher seen fighting female student in viral video arrest...
Beijing condemns US move to blacklist Chinese companies
Trump gets a cold reception at NBA Finals game as Spurs beat Knicks
One dead, fire officer hospitalised after bee attack at Quarry Site in Sokode Gb...
Israel and Iran step back from further strikes after renewed clashes
Patients stranded as doctors, nurses refuse to see new patients over KATH CEO su...
Avenor Rural Bank CEO’s house destroyed by fire
Here are areas to be affected by ECG's planned maintenance on Tuesday
SHS teacher allegedly beats female student over unpaid hostel fees
Blow to EU defence cooperation as France, Germany abandon joint fighter jet prog...
