Tuberculosis: Ugly scar on beautiful childhood
(CNS): Jugalkishore is a six year old boy whose impish smile hides the ugly germs of TB that are ravaging his health. He is the third child of Ramdulari - the charming, but uneducated, hapless wife of daily wage earner Shivprasad, who uses excessive alcohol and tobacco, and is also a former TB patient who successfully completed TB treatment. Jugalkishore, has recently been diagnosed with pulmonary TB and put on a 6 months course of free anti-tuberculosis treatment (ATT) since the last one month, at a DOTS centre. He is just one of the estimated one million children under 14 years of age who will need treatment for tuberculosis this year (approx. 10–15% of 9 million cases estimated by the WHO Global TB Control Report 2011).
Some experts believe that childhood TB is widely under-reported and can represent as much as 40% of the TB caseload in some TB high burden settings. Childhood TB ranks high on the public health priority list because TB is an important cause of child (and maternal) morbidity and mortality, and also because TB infected children are at greater risk than adults for developing active TB disease, as well as of having the TB disseminate throughout the body, including to the brain, where it causes meningitis. This type of TB is often fatal or leaves the child with major disability.
The International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease (The Union) strongly believes that, “TB case-finding efforts should target children under 5 years of age living in a household with a sputum-smear positive adult. If the children are well, they should receive isoniazid preventive treatment (IPT) to help prevent their developing active TB disease. If they are not well, TB treatment should be considered and a clinical examination is recommended.”
But the likes of Ramdulari are ignorant about the seriousness of the disease. She only knows that he son had started coughing when he was two years old, which worsened over a period of time. The cough would be particularly bad at night, and often make him breathless. The parents would take him to a government hospital for treatment, but the medicines did not improve his condition. The doctors would ask them to buy medicines from outside, which they could not afford. He was eventually diagnosed with TB in the summer of 2011 on the basis of an X Ray. The doctor prescribed medicines most of which were to be bought from the private market. As they could not afford that, treatment was discontinued. After sometime, he was very sick again, so he was admitted in the hospital for 10 days. Another X-Ray was taken, and he was also given the BCG vaccine for a third time. Only when the doctors were repeatedly told that they were too poor to buy medicines, did they prescribe free medicines from the DOTS centre.
The family has no knowledge about TB, or how it is spread. They did not even know that one gets free medicine for TB. They were not counselled about any infection control measures at the DOTS centre. The doctors did not tell them anything about cough hygiene, or about cleanliness, or how to protect others from infection. (When I met the child, he had had a severe bout of cough, and he was coughing very close to his 3 year old sister). No other family member has been asked by the doctors to get tested for TB, although the child's father has been on ATT a few years ago and is coughing again. The child sleeps with the mother on the same bed along with his siblings.
Dr Anne Detjen, Child TB specialist working with The Union's TREAT TB initiative, emphasizes that, “Contact tracing and preventive therapy are the most important measures to prevent the development of TB in children. Children in close contact to TB cases have the highest risk of becoming infected and developing disease, often severe disease, if they don't receive preventive therapy. Not tracing down those children and treating them is a missed opportunity. Early detection of TB in adults and the interruption of transmission is another important step, to prevent TB in children. This requires advocacy at the community level as well as easy access to diagnosis and treatment.”
The family of Ramdulari lives in a typical urban semi slum area (in as much as the houses are not makeshift but permanent brick structures) of Lucknow, the capital of Uttar Pradesh, which boasts of the state of art medical facilities. They reside in a brick walled house in a very narrow by lane, carefully protected from the prying rays of the sun. There is a small open verandah, leading to two dark, dingy and damp rooms, with no access to sunlight, and hardly any ventilation. One of the rooms doubles up as a kitchen, which has a mud stove run on wood fuel. The smoke from the chulha, and from the bidis smoked in the house, linger in the closed environment for long.
However according to Dr Penny Enarson, Head of the Child Lung Health Division, The Union, “Improving the detection rate/treatment in adults by the national TB Programmes and improving housing to reduce the conditions that increase transmission, especially over-crowding, would affect the incidence in TB in children drastically.”
Ramdulari has 4 children, but she never had any institutional delivery. Like her other kids, Jugal Kishore too was born at home. He was an underweight infant and could be only partially breast fed due to the poor health of his mother. There is never enough to eat in the house, let alone milk or any other nutritive food for the children. Ramdulari has to manage a family of seven on the meagre earnings of around Rs 100 to Rs 150 ($2 or 3) per day, a major part of which is spent on the liquor and bidis of his husband, who has been coughing a lot of late. But he has not gone to the doctor, as he feels he has already completed the treatment of TB once, so he will not have it again.
The case of Jugalkishore is not an isolated one. There are innumerable tales of neglect and apathy, which dampen the success stories of the government programmes. But if this is the situation in a metro city, one can well imagine what the situation would be in rural and remote areas. It may sound politically correct to cry hoarse in unison that we want a TB Free World by 2015, but merely chanting slogans are not going to make any difference in the lives of people like Ramdulari and her kids. One has to see what can be improved in the existing setup. Only if there was prompt diagnosis of TB and better contact tracing; only if the much publicised maternal and child health programmes of the government could reach these unreached populations; only if women could be made aware and counselled about family planning, exclusive breast feeding and basic health/hygiene measures; only if the healthcare services were more receptive to the needs of the poor people. The list may seem endless, yet it is achievable without any extra resources. A little more competency and accountability in our work, instead of a 'couldn't care less attitude', will go a long way in controlling childhood TB.
Dr Steve Graham, Child Lung Health division, The Union, and Chair, Child TB Subgroup of the DOTS Expansion Working Group of Stop TB Partnership, rightly insists that, “Improved case finding and increased use of preventive therapy, are the two most important, yet simple, interventions in resource limited settings which can bring down the incidence of childhood TB. Both of these are the target of routine screening of close contacts of TB cases and are currently available. Of course, also improved vaccine and improved accuracy of diagnostic tools (which could be simple but are not yet available).”
For more than a decade, The Union has been providing a major forum for clinicians, researchers and advocates in child TB through its annual World Conference. It has also provided important resources, including courses on child lung health; technical guides, such as the Desk-guide on diagnosis and management of TB in children; and research published in the monthly International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease. It also supports National Tuberculosis Programmes in high-burden countries through technical assistance and training and also by providing input into the research agenda, including the work on new diagnostics that is so critical for addressing child TB. (CNS)
Shobha Shukla - CNS
(The author is the Managing Editor of Citizen News Service (CNS). She is a J2J Fellow of National Press Foundation (NPF) USA. She has worked earlier with State Planning Institute, UP and taught physics at India's prestigious Loreto Convent. She also authored “Saving Children from TB” book (2012), co-authored (translated in three languages) "Voices from the field on childhood pneumonia" book (2011), and a report on Hepatitis C and HIV treatment access issues in 2011. Email: email@example.com, website: http://www.citizen-news.org)